How to make a Pie Crust

Posted on August 4, 2008 
Filed Under How to..., Pies

Ok, I’ll just show you how I do it, but don’t expect alot of tips and all. Who knows, after this post, you might be giving me a lot of tips! ūüėČ That would be great, it would make us all better pie crust makers. And you might laugh at how I do it, for example,¬†I use Saran Wrap in the pie-crust-making process. *Huh?!*

Warning: Eyes may glaze over… there are lots of pictures and it got a little wordy. :)

First, the recipe. This is the only pie crust recipe I use and I don’t even try others because this one works great and has only 4 ingredients and¬†it gets¬†compliments now and then:

Pie Crust

1 1/3 cups flour
1/2 tsp. salt
1/2 cup¬†butter-flavored shortening (Does shortening have an ‘e’ in it? I keep adding then erasing it. I should go look on the can.)
3 Tbsp. ice water

I put the flour and¬†salt into a bowl and give it a few stirs w\ the teaspoon that¬†I measured the salt with. Yeah, I about always measure stuff, I’m not one of those ‘just dump it in’ people.¬†Then, I mix the shortening in with a potato masher…
pie-crust2.jpg¬† I’ve tried a pastry blender, two knives, a fork, and nothing works quite as good as a potato masher.¬†
pie-crust3.jpg

pie-crust4.jpg

pie-crust5.jpg
When it looks about like this, pour the water in all at once and quickly stir it with a fork. More like pourthewaterinallatonceandquicklystiritwithafork. Not sure why, but I feel some urgency to get it stirred in, maybe because I’m afraid it would soak into the part where it’s pooled, then not get evenly dispersed. Anyway,¬†I think that little tidbit might fall under the category of ‘Weird Quirks’ instead of ‘Pie-Crust-Making Tips’.

When it looks like this,
pie-crust6.jpg
stop stirring and get a piece of Saran wrap, lay it on the counter, and sprinkle it with flour. Then, with your hands, get all the dough and squeeze it together into a ball, then flatten it a bit and put it on the floured Saran wrap.
pie-crust7.jpg

Sprinkle flour over the top.
pie-crust8.jpg
Take the rolling pin and roll it this way,
pie-crust9.jpg
then that way.
pie-crust10.jpg
Sprinkle some more flour on because the rolling pin will be starting to stick a little.
pie-crust11.jpg
Roll it out some more till it’s a couple inches bigger than the pie plate all the way around. Put one hand under the Saran wrap and the other hand on the back of the pie plate, and flip¬†the whole works¬†over.
pie-crust12.jpg

pie-crust13.jpg
Peel off the Saran wrap. Now, here’s an actual tip: Instead of just pressing the crust down into the pan, lift it up off the edge and let it line the pan without pushing down on it. Otherwise it will stretch the dough, then it’ll shrink when it bakes. I don’t really know how to explain it, but just¬†DON’T make the dough stretch by pressing it down into where the side and bottom of pan meet.
pie-crust14.jpg¬†You can’t really see it, but I’m not just pressing the dough down in with my fingertips… I’m lifting up the edge and putting it down in to line the ‘corner’. Once it’s all in there, press down a little around the top edge, this’ll make it easier to cut the extra dough¬†off. Take a knife and cut it off.
pie-crust15.jpg

Here’s where my extra dough always goes…
pie-crust16.jpg
And she’d get my camera and take pictures of her own pie dough creations. Close up pictures. And the camera would focus on stuff behind the subject being photographed…
pie-crust20.jpg 

I usually crimp the edges of the dough between my thumb and finger.
pie-crust17.jpg

Poke the bottom and side of crust with a fork.
pie-crust18.jpg

pie-crust19.jpg

Bake at 375 for 12-15 minutes. And you’ve got a pie crust.
pie-crust21.jpg
Yeah, it does shrink just a¬†tiny bit, but it’s good enough for me.¬†I’d rather have that than¬†mess with putting beans in it to bake it.

And, last but not least,¬†the famous pie crust question… Is it flaky? I think so…
pie-crust1.jpg

Now, let’s hear from you…¬†I know alot of you out there make pies. Please give us some more tips! :)

Comments

10 Responses to “How to make a Pie Crust”

  1. Traci on August 4th, 2008 5:00 pm

    Oh my, I LOVE you!!! I have needed this like you don’t even know…..THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU.

  2. Michelle on August 4th, 2008 5:13 pm

    Maybe I can make my own pie crust now. I’ve tried to make pie crusts in the past and I’ve always had trouble with rolling them out and getting them in the pan. So I gave up and I buy them at a bulk food store where they’re in the pan ready to go and all you have to is bake them. Very convenient!! I’ll have to give this a try sometime. Thanks for the good tips!

  3. Shannon on August 4th, 2008 7:38 pm

    Hum, I like that saran wrap deal. I always had trouble dealing the dumb stuff off the counter. The last pecan pie I made, the crust SOME HOW lifted off the bottom of the pan while baking and all the filling went underneath, so the crust was right up against the top… explain that one to me. I was mad! I am going to try this again. I really am. Maybe soon you can just make all my pies for me. Please?

  4. Freida on August 4th, 2008 7:44 pm

    I’d say you got it pretty good. The saran wrap is defintely not a quirk. I do that too, altho I use wax paper. Probably not much difference. Looks good. Puts me in the mood for pie again. I should do your peanut butter pie.

  5. Kay on the farm in Neb on August 5th, 2008 4:51 am

    Do you have trouble with the dough developing gluten by mixing the water in quickly? I was taught to always “gently” toss the flour/shortening (yes an “e”) with the water, a tsp at a time. Next time I’ll just dump and stir.
    Peaches are coming into the stores now. Colorado peaches…mmmmmmm

  6. Jan on August 5th, 2008 5:52 am

    Thank-you! I’ve been wondering how to make a buttery pie crust, like I’ve had elsewhere. Bingo: butter Crisco! I’ve been getting hungry for pie and will try this one out. My crust recipe works, but I never was quiet satisfied b/c it wasn’t buttery.

  7. Cordy on August 6th, 2008 8:07 pm

    Your kindness just blesses me! Thanks SO much Kay!

  8. Suzanne on December 28th, 2008 6:12 pm

    I don’t know if you guys have done this, but with the extra pie crust clippings, my grandma always (and to this day still does), takes the leftovers and rolls them out into an oval-type shape. She then sprinkles cinnamon sugar on it and rolls it up. She calls them “roly-polies.” They are almost as good as her pie!

  9. Rhoda on June 16th, 2009 7:54 am

    I used to work at a bakery and we would always insert another pie pan on top of the crust and then bake it…an easy alternative to the ‘beans’ you were talking about. i never heard of using the beans. what do the beans do? I still use the extra pie pan inserted on top of the crust when i bake my own crusts.

  10. Ashley Nicole on August 25th, 2009 7:45 am

    Hey SuzAnne. I always do that w/ my pie crust. Thats my favorite part when it comes to making pies. Thankyou Kay for this recipe. I used it last night and it turned out perfect. It was easy too.

Leave a Reply